Monday, February 18, 2013

Milk, Juice, Carrot Lab


These three lab experiments were assigned for my BIO156 class, but they became a fun family project for our Science Saturday.  The kids were lab assistants, and enjoyed being able to participate by writing down their own hypotheses.  when the projects were done we discussed what had happened and why which was a great learning experience for us all, and was a great way for me to review as well!  These are all ones that kids can do with help, so feel free to try them!

LAB
MILK, JUICE, CARROT

This exercise has three parts. As you work, please take photographs of what you are doing and record your results.  Three or four photographs of each part should be enough to show the steps and your final result. For each experiment, you will be asked to formulate a hypothesis. Make sure you understand what this is. Write complete, proper sentences, please. Have fun!
Part 1 Milk

Objective: Observe and explain changes occurring in milk due to biological influences

Materials:
Milk
Shallow cup or jar

1.       Pour ½ cup milk into a shallow cup or jar.
2.       Place in a warm, dark place for about three days.
3.       Record what you think will happen to the milk and why you believe this will happen. This is your hypothesis.
4.       At the end of the three days, observe the milk and record what your senses detect.
5.       Explain why any changes (if any) occurred.
6.       List any factors that are playing a part. What could you call what you made (if you had a change in the milk)? Really think about this in terms of cell respiration and any organisms which could play a role.
7.       Record  your  hypothesis, observations, explanation, and factors separately from these instructions. You will see a place for them on the last page.

Part 2 Juice

Objective: Witness the mixing action of molecules and describe the process

Materials:
3 cups or jars
6 cups water
½ cup fruit juice—grape, cranberry, or another that is dark in color

1.       Set up the jars or cups as follows:
Pour 2 cups of room temperature water in Cup 1
Pour 2 cups of ice water in Cup 2
Pour 2 cups of boiling water in Cup 3
2.       Slowly pour one-third of the juice into Cup 1. Observe and record
3.       Repeat for Cup 2 and Cup 3.
4.       Give detailed observations and comparisons between the behaviors of the solutions in the three cups.
5.       Explain why the differences have occurred in terms of the behavior of molecules and what might influence their behavior.
6.       Write your observations and explanation separately from these instructions. You will see a place for them on the last page.

Part 3 Carrot

Before you begin, review the main parts of a cell and particle movement.

Objective:  Investigate cellular functions and cellular structures using a carrot


Materials:

2 jars or cups
string
water
    salt
    masking tape
    carrot
knife
ruler


1.       Pour two cups of water into two jars or cups. Add one teaspoon of salt into one and label it "Salt Water" with a piece of masking tape. Label the other beaker "Fresh Water."

2.       Cut a fresh carrot in half. Measure the length and width of both pieces and record this measurement on the answer sheet. Tie a piece of string just below the cut side of the carrot on both pieces. Tie the string tightly.

3.       Set one carrot with the cut-end side down into one jar and the other with the cut-end side down in the second jar.  Allow the carrots to sit in the jars for 24 hours.

4.       Before you observe results of the experiment, write down what you think will happen to each carrot in this experiment and why you believe this will happen. This is your hypothesis.

5.       Remove the carrots and examine the tightness of the strings. Re-measure the carrots and record the findings.

6.       Note if there are any differences in the tightness of the strings and the textures for both carrot pieces. Observe which type of water caused an increase in carrot size. Observe which type of water caused a decrease in carrot size.

7.       Initial length and width of carrot pieces:

Piece 1

Piece 2

After-experiment length and width of carrot pieces:

Piece 1

Piece 2


Record your hypothesis, tightness of string and texture observations and measurements separately from these instructions. You will see a place for them on the last page.






Answers
Record your answers here, space out as needed, and copy and paste them into your blog. Include three or so photos for each part to illustrate the process of the experiment. Thanks!
Milk: Record your hypothesis, observations, explanation, and factors here.

 Hypothesis: The milk will curdle creating a semi-solid curd of the condensed white blood cells, lipids, etc and a watery whey will come to the top.

Observations
The milk created a semi-solid in the center bottom of the cut and a cloudy, watery liquid collected on the top.  The solid portion dislodged from the bottom and made the water a little cloudier when I move it from the location where is sat during the test to take this photo.

Although I knew that milk curdles, and knew to expect this result before performing the test (with 4 kids I have had more than one sippy cup lost under the couch for a couple of days) I wasn't quite sure why this happens.  It turns out that the reason that the milk proteins associate and form into the curd is because the pH of the milk changes.  As bacteria grows in the milk, they bacteria produces lactic acid which raises the pH and causes the normally disassociated milk proteins (casein) to start to clump together.  This process can be artificially produced with other acids such as lemon juice. 

Source:
Why Does Milk Curdle?. Bethany Moncel. http://foodreference.about.com/od/Dairy/a/Why-Does-Milk-Curdle.htm. Accessed 18 February 2013.


Juice: Write your observations and explanation here.
 HypothesisThe warmer the water the faster the juice will diffuse into solution.

Observations:
Materials ready for the juice lab- ice water, room temp water, boiling water (left to right).

When juice was added to the ice water the juice went to the bottom and mixed with the water.  There was still clear water on the top, but below that the juice a water mixed.  Right after pour the juice in it could be seen swirling in the jar and mixing with the water.


The juice added to the room temperature water could be seen swirling and mixing with it and seemed to turn into a complete solution with the water rather quickly.


This really didn't photograph well, but in the boiling water the juice blended with the water but resulted in a solution that faded through the jar.  It was darkest at the bottom and then still looked like clear water at the top.

Diffusion is the mixing of two substances through kinetic means.  The particles of each are moving, and eventually intermingle enough to create a solution where they are evenly distributed.  Thermal energy can speed this process.  The juice added to the ice water was taking much longer to disperse evenly with the juice because at a lower temperature the molecules are moving more slowly.  At higher temperatures the molecules are more excited and are moving much faster due to thermal energy.  I was puzzle though by the gradiated color in the boiling water jar.

Source:
Diffusion. Georgia State University. http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/kinetic/diffus.html. Accessed 18 February 2013.



Carrot:  Record your hypothesis, tightness of string and texture observations and measurements, and what type of water caused shrinkage or expansion here.

Hypothesis: The carrot in fresh water will remain firm and fresh, while the carrot in salt water will behome dehydrated and shrivel.

Observations:

Initial length and width of carrot pieces:

Piece 1: 9 cm long, 7.5 cm circumference (Fresh Water)

Piece 2: 9 cm long, 7.5 cm circumference (Salt Water)

After-experiment length and width of carrot pieces:

Piece 1: 9.5 cm long 8 cm circumference (Fresh Water)

Piece 2: 9 cm long, 7.3 cm circumference (Salt Water)


After soaking in their respective jars for 28 hours the carrots were observed a second time.  There was measurable shrinkage in the circumference of the carrot that had been submerged in salt water, while the carrot that had been submerged in fresh water had increased in size.  Before tying the string on the carrots, it was soaked in water to allow for any stretching the might occur when it got wet.  After the testing period the string was still very tight on the fresh water sample.  On the salt water sample, the string still stayed in place, but could be moved down towards the cut end of the carrot with minor effort.  When it was moved the area where it had been tied was obviously indented with markings from the string.  The area towards the cut end of the salt water sample also felt somewhat more pliable than before the test, and as compared to the other sample.

The sample that was in the salt water lost volume because of diffusion.  The water was a salt solution, meaning that there was a higher sodium content outside of the carrot than inside.  This will pull water out of the carrot through osmosis to try and make the NaCl levels even between the two areas.  As water leaves the carrot cells they become dehydrated and lose their normal structure and functionality.  In the fresh water sample water moves into the carrot through osmosis as in a somewhat opposite process.  Because the water is not pure H2O it is unlikely that it will overfill the cells and burst them, but in a pure environment this would happen.

Source:
Human Biology Sixth Edition: Structure and Function of Cells (p58). Michael D. Johnson. print.

Unit 1 Paper


This posting is a unit paper and review of the first portion of my BIO156 Semester.  Although Part2 is simply reflection on the class, I would recommend Part1 to readers who aren't interested in the course anyway.  It is about a topic that I found most compelling in the first part of the semester.  A piece in the textbook focused on the use of vitamins and supplements.  For this assignment we were challenged to do more research on our chosen topic, and I believe people should be aware of the things that I found so that they can be informed consumers.


Part 1:

Dietary Supplements, Dangerous?

In our first unit in BIO156 this semester we covered so much ground.  One aspect of this that I found to be particularly interesting was a section in the book about dietary supplements.  There are two types of dietary supplements, those that are packaged and sold as such, and so-called functional foods.  I have always had some interest in more "traditional" medicine and surprised to find out how little research is done in this area.  It makes sense when it comes to functional foods, because the health benefits are said to be natural properties of the foods.  Testing this could be extremely difficult, and expensive, and there isn't a lot of interest in doing so because it wouldn't be very cost effective for companies.  The reasoning for supplements was somewhat similar  but I was shocked at how little oversight there is on the production of these products.  There are huge regulatory issues that go along with supplements because they simply aren't regulated.  As we learned about cell function in our class and how important balance within the body is to maintaining proper function through homeostasis, it made me question even more why people are so accepting of there being little to no research or testing on these products or regulations on their contents.  I take a couple of basic supplements, and have always used some basic herbal remedies.  I feel like there should be a lot more research into herbal and traditional medicine than there currently is because some of those things seem to have worked for people very well for hundreds of years.  As far as the supplements go, I would really like to be able to trust that a supplement I am taking is what it says it is, and isn't full of a lot of junk that I don't want or need in my body!

Photo Credit
Information on the FDA's own website is confusing.  Their statement on dietary supplements states that "generally, manufacturers do not need to register their products with FDA nor get FDA approval before producing or selling dietary supplements (Dietary Supplements)"  This makes their previous statement that, "FDA regulates both finished dietary supplement products and dietary ingredients" seem inaccurate (Dietary Supplements).  From reading their site I learned that the FDA does hold companies accountable for the safety of their products, requiring that any adverse effect incidents be reported, and both that products be safe, and that their labeling not be misleading.  However, since these companies aren't required to register their products it seems like enforcement would be difficult.  An article on the FDA's own site warns about taking the supplement WOW because it allegedly contains Reumofan Plus, a substance that they had previously warned about being dangerous to consumers (Dangerous Supplement).  Although the article says that they had previously warned about the product, and that it contained dangerous things that should only be used under a doctor's direct supervision, they apparently didn't move to ban the substance.  Instead, when companies rebranded the product to try and sell off reserve stock, the FDA simply put out another warning.  What is most concerning about this whole issue is that people are taking multivitamins and supplements because they believe that they will improve or help them maintain their health.    According to an article published by MedLine Plus, Less than a quarter of people who take multivitamins do so because their doctor recommended it(Benefits Unproven).  People's belief in the power of vitamins and supplements comes at a big cost.  The industry brings in $30 billion per year in the United States (Benefits Unproven).  The contents of these pills however is not monitored, and there can be unexpected ingredients.  Not only that, because there is no testing required on their benefits, they can be a huge waste of money.  And in come cases research that has been done indicates that artificially high levels of some vitamins and minerals can cause complications other than hypervitaminosis (Calcium Supplements).
Photo Credit
So what have we learned from this?  1.The FDA states that they regulate vitamins and supplements, albeit under different guideline from their other food and drug regulations.  2.Through these regulations, the FDA holds companies accountable for their product's safety  though they are not required to even register their products before releasing them into the marketplace.  3.The FDA does not however have much power over supplements, and simply issues warnings instead of banning or limiting concerning substances. 4.People take multivitamins and supplements because of a belief that they will support health, spending billions of dollars every year, despite there being little to no proof of the benefits.  What can you do?  Ask you physician.  If you are using an supplements make sure that your physician knows as they can interact with and cause complications with medications or medical procedures.  But the best thing that you as a consumer can do is to be aware.  Check the history of the company that makes any supplements that you use.  Read all the labeling and ask critical questions.
Sources:
Calcium Supplements May Raise Odds of Heart Death in Women. HealthDay. http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/news/fullstory_133948.html. Accessed 18 February 2013.
Dangerous Supplement Now Sold as 'WOW'. FDA. http://www.fda.gov/ForConsumers/ConsumerUpdates/ucm333188.htm. Accessed 18 February 2013.
Dietary Supplements. FDA. http://www.fda.gov/Food/DietarySupplements/default.htm. Accessed 17 February 2013.
With Benefits Unproven, Why Do Millions of Americans Take Multivitamins?. Healthy Day. http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/news/fullstory_133698.html. Accessed 18 February 2013.


Part 2. Thinking About the Course (In complete sentences, numbered answers, no word limits)
  1. What one assignment or activity you performed in this unit are you the most proud of? I really liked doing the DNA extraction lab.  I did very well on the assignment and enjoyed completing it as well.  It was the first time that I had interacted with an online lab tool like that so I was really pleased with how smoothly I got through it.  I also really liked how detailed it was, and felt like I had a hands on experience in doing it even though I wasn't able to physically do the work myself at home.
  2. What do you now understand best about the information in this unit?  After completing this unit, I feel like I have a much greater understanding of cell function, and specifically the transport methods used by cells.  The different kinds of passive and active transport that go on in cells was covered quite well through the course, and assigned lab activities also helped to make the ideas more tangible.  Diffusion through simple osmosis through the lipid bilayer, through channels, gated channels, and facilitated transport are all forms of passive transport that were illustrated well in the material, as was active transport.  Through understanding of these, and the ways in which our cells function I feel like I ave a greater understanding of how important homeostasis is.  For me this has real world application for athletic endeavors   By better understanding how cells absorb the materials they need to function their best, I can work to feed my cells properly before, during and after activity to maximize my performance and health through the process.
  3. What actions did you take for yourself to enhance learning or enjoyment of the material? As I mentioned in my answer to number 2, I tried to apply what I was learning to my own life in a greater sense   Understanding the most basic structures of our bodies and how they function can help us to reach for our own health goals and achievements in a more proactive way.  I also tried to include my kids in my lab projects when possible.  It became a time of discovery and learning for all of us together!
  4. When did you feel most “connected” with the course? Most distanced? I have felt most connected with the course when I have been able to do hands on activities that demonstrate the concepts in the book.  Both through physical, and through virtual, online labs.  I also really like when I can take something like cell function, and look at it on a larger scale.  How does cell function play a role in what I need to do as an athlete for example?  By looking for ways where this information is directly connected with my life on a greater scale, I have found it easier to be excited about learning and understanding the material.  I found the chemistry part of the course most distancing.  I haven't taken a chemistry class in over a decade, and don't remember doing very well with it at that time either.  Suddenly facing biochem without having someone who could explain it in person was kind of overwhelming.  I ended up doing okay on the lab work for that section but it took hours for me to complete what I'm sure should have taken far less time.
  5. What could I offer you to help your understanding or enjoyment of the material?  I would really like a hands on molecule lab.  A virtual lab where we can manipulate molecules to better understand their bonding and structures would be a great way to help with the chemistry and molecule portion.  Something were students can create and break apart molecules, see the valance electrons, and be able to manipulate elements to be able to create and see the different kinds of bonds and structures of basic molecules of life.